Korean Music Industry Insiders Suggest The Reign Of Girls' Generation May Soon Be Over

In a Korea Times feature about the current state of Girls' Generation, some Korean music industry insiders suggest that the famed girl group is nearing disbandment.

Despite being regarded as the most popular K-Pop girl group with dedicated fans around the globe, is Girls' Generation on the way out? That is was some Korean music industry professionals seem to think.

In a piece published in the Korea Times last week, it was suggested that the recently revealed relationships and scandals surrounding a few of the band's members provide evidence that the nine-member K-Pop group is running out of steam.

Girls' Generation is managed by big-time Korean entertainment agency SM Entertainment, a record label notorious for keeping its artists on a tight leash. But the recent announcement that three of the group's members, Yoona, Sooyoung, and Tiffany, are officially off the market and involved in some very high-profile relationships has raised more than a few eyebrows.

Another member, Hyoyeon, was also caught up in an alleged assault, which turned out to be false, but nonetheless revealed that she, too, had been involved in a two-year relationship.

Because the four incidents were exposed in a relatively short period of time, many have questioned SM's decision to lift the dating-ban previously imposed on the members and what it means for the future of the group.

In recent history, when a member of a famous Korean girl group has gone public with a romantic relationship, her popularity, as well as the popularity of her group, has diminished. This is generally credited to the fact that many fans would prefer the stars to stay young and pure forever. It is for that reason that many contracts offered by these agencies include strict no-dating clauses in addition to regulations about the artists' daily lives.

In the eight years since Girls' Generation debuted in South Korea, this is the first time that such details of the members' personal lives have been revealed, making some wonder if SM merely lifted the ban on dating due to the increasing age of the girls, or if the singers themselves have instigated some sort of dating rebellion.

"It's quite unusual," explained one K-Pop label representative who remained nameless in the Korea Times article. "I personally suspect that SM has drastically loosened its grip on Girls' Generation members or they were out of control." He also added that there is no way of knowing for sure that the remaining five "scandal-free" members have not had any sort of dating experience.

It is also important to note, that as with most women in their mid-20s, there is nothing unusual about the Girls' Generation members dating.

In an interview with another member, Sunny, published in Sports Hankook last Wednesday she said, "You are watching us grow, the unedited version. I turned 25, not young anymore. I have many married friends, including those with babies."

She added, "Perhaps there are people who have difficulty in accepting the fact that we are getting mature. But that is true and an undeniable reality. Personally speaking, I'm positive about becoming mature."

Sunny's unabashed comments suggest that Girls' Generation may have won freedom over their personal lives and that more relationships may come to light in the approaching months.

"That may be welcoming news for them," said another unnamed industry insider to the Korea Times. "But we need to know why SM lifted the (dating) ban despite knowing that a dating scandal only carries a negative impact on their popularity. My premature conclusion is that the band's life is coming to an end."

The fact of the matter is that Girls' Generation has already had a career that extends far beyond the average life expectancy of most K-Pop girl groups, who tend to top out at about five years.

Couple that with the changing times and we may very well see more idols admitting relationships. It is also equally likely that there will soon be a general decrease in the popularity and power of girl groups by and large, who are increasingly considered less valuable when compared to their peers and competitors making strides in the realm of writing, composing, and producing their own music.

What does the future have in store for Korea's favorite girl group? Only time will tell for sure. It may be a while until the lasting effects of these relationships, if any, are known.

In the meantime, what do you think? Will the personal lives of the Girls' Generation members ultimately cause the downfall of the group, or will their fanbase remain devoted and loyal until the very end? Leave your thoughts in the comments section below.

For the full Korea Times article, click HERE.

Tags
Girls Generation
Yoona
Sooyoung
Hyoyeon
Sunny
Tiffany
Join the Discussion

Latest Photo Gallery

Real Time Analytics